Close Menu

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    What's Hot

    We’re At A Crucial Point Where Difficult Decisions Will Be Made – Fubara

    May 29, 2025

    Ex-CBN Governor Emefiele Appeals Seizure Of 753 Housing Units By FG

    May 29, 2025

    Breaking: Elon Musk Quits Trump’s Administration

    May 29, 2025
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • We’re At A Crucial Point Where Difficult Decisions Will Be Made – Fubara
    • Ex-CBN Governor Emefiele Appeals Seizure Of 753 Housing Units By FG
    • Breaking: Elon Musk Quits Trump’s Administration
    • PDP Drags Oluwole Oke to Court Over Defection to APC
    • We Are Working Towards Increasing Ground Rent Charges – Wike
    • Outpouring of Condolences As Kenyan Author, Ngugi wa Thiong’o Dies At 87
    • Israeli Forces Killed Hamas Leader, Mohammed Sinwar – Netanyahu
    • Radio Biafra: Prosecutor Says Nnamdi Kanu Admitted Smuggling Radio Transmitter Into Nigeria
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    TheScrutinyNG
    Subscribe
    Friday, May 30
    • Home
    • Politics
    • Business
    • News
      • World News
    • Sports
    • Interviews
    • Opinion
    • Entertainment
    • Columnists
    • ABOUT US
    TheScrutinyNG
    Home » The Dangerous Trend Of Misinterpreting Supreme Court Judgements In Nigeria: A Call For Urgent Sanity
    4 Mins ReadApril 10, 2025

    The Dangerous Trend Of Misinterpreting Supreme Court Judgements In Nigeria: A Call For Urgent Sanity

    By TheScrutinyNGApril 10, 2025No Comments4 Mins Read
    Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    By Dr. Monday O. Ubani (SAN)

    In recent times, a disturbing and dangerous trend has emerged within the Nigerian legal and political landscape. It is the deliberate misinterpretation and misrepresentation of final court judgements, particularly those of the Supreme Court, by parties to suits. Rather than submitting to the authority and finality of these decisions, parties now cherry-pick aspects of the judgements that suit their personal or political interests, often spinning misleading narratives that cause confusion, tension, and disorder within the polity.

    This trend has played out brazenly in several recent cases, the most notable being:

    1. The case of Governor Siminalayi Fubara and the Rivers State House of Assembly, where parties to the dispute have offered conflicting interpretations of the Supreme Court’s ruling, particularly in relation to the status and validity of the Assembly’s actions post-defection, as well as the Governor’s compliance with purported agreements.

     2. The PDP leadership tussle involving Mr. Samuel Anyanwu and Mr. Sunday Udeh- Okoye, in which the Supreme Court’s pronouncement was supposed to end the internal wrangling. Yet, both sides claimed victory, creating further ambiguity and exacerbating the conflict within the party.

    3. The Labour Party’s leadership crisis, especially concerning the legitimacy and tenure of the party chairman. Despite a clear judicial pronouncement, the contending factions have continued to hold opposing positions, undermining the authority of the court’s decision.

    In all these matters, the Supreme Court, as the final arbiter of justice in Nigeria, has made pronouncements that ought to bring finality to the disputes. Yet, parties have manipulated these judgements to suit their selfish agendas, leading to public confusion and a deepening of the very conflicts the court sought to resolve.

    This development is dangerous for several compelling reasons:

    1. It undermines the finality of the Supreme Court. If judgements of the apex court are subject to multiple interpretations by parties, it threatens the very foundation of our judicial system. The authority and integrity of the judiciary are eroded when parties treat final court decisions as mere opinions rather than binding mandates.

     2. It perpetuates endless litigation and conflict. If there is no common understanding and acceptance of a final judgement, then there can be no end to disputes. The essence of judicial resolution is defeated when parties act contrary to the spirit and letter of a ruling.

     3. It erodes public confidence in the judicial process. When the public sees that court decisions do not bring resolution or certainty, they may begin to question the relevance of the courts. This undermines the rule of law and fosters a culture of lawlessness and disrespect for judicial authority.

    To arrest this growing menace, I propose the following urgent measures:

    1. The Supreme Court must make its judgements more explicit and unambiguous. Where necessary, the court should provide clear consequential orders to eliminate room for manipulation and mischief by litigants or their legal representatives.

    2. Legal practitioners must uphold the highest standards of professional ethics. Lawyers should advise their clients honestly and responsibly, even if the court’s decision is unfavourable. It is unprofessional and dangerous for lawyers to become merchants of confusion by spinning judgements to favour their clients’ desires rather than the truth.

    3. Contempt proceedings must be actively pursued against defaulters. Parties who willfully misinterpret or defy court judgements must be held accountable. The courts should not hesitate to invoke their contempt powers to punish such conduct, which seeks to bring the judiciary into disrepute.

    My conclusion is that  the judiciary remains the last hope of the common man. If the sanctity of its decisions is not preserved and enforced, the very fabric of our democratic governance will be at risk. All stakeholders – lawyers, litigants, political actors, and the media  must play their part in respecting and upholding the finality and authority of the Supreme Court. This is the only way to ensure peace, order, and the continued relevance of the judicial institution in our democratic experiment.

    Ubani, a human rights lawyer writes from Lagos

     

    Author

    • TheScrutinyNG
      TheScrutinyNG

      View all posts
    Monday Onyekachi Ubani SAN Supreme Court
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    TheScrutinyNG
    • Website

    Related Posts

    Featured

    We’re At A Crucial Point Where Difficult Decisions Will Be Made – Fubara

    May 29, 2025
    Banking & Finance

    Ex-CBN Governor Emefiele Appeals Seizure Of 753 Housing Units By FG

    May 29, 2025
    Breaking News

    Breaking: Elon Musk Quits Trump’s Administration

    May 29, 2025
    Featured

    PDP Drags Oluwole Oke to Court Over Defection to APC

    May 29, 2025
    Business

    We Are Working Towards Increasing Ground Rent Charges – Wike

    May 29, 2025
    Breaking News

    Outpouring of Condolences As Kenyan Author, Ngugi wa Thiong’o Dies At 87

    May 29, 2025

    Subscribe to News

    Get the latest sports news from NewsSite about world, sports and politics.

    Editor's Picks

    We’re At A Crucial Point Where Difficult Decisions Will Be Made – Fubara

    May 29, 2025

    Ex-CBN Governor Emefiele Appeals Seizure Of 753 Housing Units By FG

    May 29, 2025

    Breaking: Elon Musk Quits Trump’s Administration

    May 29, 2025

    PDP Drags Oluwole Oke to Court Over Defection to APC

    May 29, 2025
    Latest Posts
    Advertisement
    Facebook X (Twitter) Pinterest Vimeo WhatsApp TikTok Instagram

    News

    • World
    • US Politics
    • EU Politics
    • Business
    • Opinions
    • Connections
    • Science

    Company

    • Information
    • Advertising
    • Classified Ads
    • Contact Info
    • Do Not Sell Data
    • GDPR Policy
    • Media Kits

    Services

    • Subscriptions
    • Customer Support
    • Bulk Packages
    • Newsletters
    • Sponsored News
    • Work With Us

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    © 2025 The Scrutiny. Designed by Design Streams.

    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms
    • Accessibility

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.